Last Thanksgiving I was halfway through a pumpkin pie when the recipe asked for ground ginger. I knew we had some. I pulled 31 jars out of one upper cabinet, set them on the counter in a crooked line, and found two cinnamons, three paprikas, a jar of cumin from the year we moved in, and no ginger. I made the pie without it. Nobody noticed, but I did.
That counter of jars is where these spice organization ideas started. I’m not a chef and our kitchen is ordinary: one cabinet next to the stove, one deep drawer, and a pantry shelf. Below is how I sorted, cut, and stored our spices so I can find one in about five seconds, plus what I tried first that didn’t hold up.
Pull every jar out and count them
I know. Everyone says “empty it first.” I used to skip it and shuffle jars around instead. But the count is the whole point, because you can’t see duplicates while they’re hiding behind each other.
My 31 jars broke down like this:
- 9 I use every week (salt, pepper, garlic powder, cumin, chili powder, oregano, cinnamon, paprika, red pepper flakes)
- 11 I use for specific dishes or holiday baking
- 6 duplicates, opened, sitting at different levels
- 5 I couldn’t remember buying, including a jar of fenugreek with no date
It took 15 minutes with a damp cloth for the sticky bottoms. If you do one thing this week, do this part.
Smell test what you keep
Spices don’t go bad the way milk does. They get weak. Penn State Extension suggests checking ground spices and herbs after about six months and replacing them once the aroma fades. It also notes that whole spices keep their quality longer than ground ones.
My test is simple. I rub a pinch between my fingers and smell it. If the paprika smells like dust, it goes. That cumin from move-in day smelled like nothing at all. Five jars went straight into the compost, and the empty glass ones went into the dishwasher to reuse.
Duplicates got combined into one jar, only when they were the same spice from roughly the same time. I didn’t pour an old cinnamon into a fresh one. That ruins the fresh one.
Keep, combine, or toss: the spice sort I use now
| What you find | What I do with it | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Strong smell, used in the last month | Keep, front row | These are the weekly ones |
| Strong smell, only for one dish or the holidays | Keep, back row or a labeled bin | Worth having, not worth prime space |
| Two opened jars of the same spice, similar age | Combine into one | Frees a spot and stops me buying a third |
| Faint or dusty smell | Toss, rinse the jar | It won’t add flavor anymore |
| Bought for one recipe, never used again | Use it this month or give it away | A neighbor who cooks that dish will use it |
| Big warehouse-store bag | Refill a small jar, store the rest airtight in the pantry | Opening the big bag near the stove lets in heat and steam |
Spice organization ideas for a cabinet
Most of our spices live in a cabinet, and the problem there is depth. A jar in the back row might as well not exist. Two cheap fixes changed that:
- A three-tier riser, $12. The back row sits higher than the front, so I can read every label from the counter.
- A small turntable on the other side of the shelf for oils and the tall jars that don’t fit the riser. One spin and the back is the front.
I put the nine weekly spices on the bottom step of the riser, closest to me. The holiday baking set went up top, together, so in November I pull that whole row forward.
One thing I moved on purpose: our spices used to sit in the cabinet right above the stove. NDSU Extension points out that heat and moisture weaken spices and suggests not storing them near the oven or dishwasher. They now live one cabinet over. It’s two steps further and I don’t miss it.
If your cabinets are the awkward corner kind, I wrote about the blind corner in corner cabinet organization. Spices are one of the things I’d keep out of a corner.
Spice drawer organization ideas (my favorite fix)
If you have one drawer near the stove you can spare, this is the setup I’d pick again. Jars lie on their side in an angled insert, labels face up, and you see all of them at once when you pull the drawer open. Nothing hides.
Our drawer is 15 inches wide and holds 24 jars in a two-tier insert I bought for $18. I measured the inside of the drawer first, not the front of it, after I got that wrong once with a different organizer and had to return it.
Lids-only labels help here. I wrote the name on top of each lid with a paint pen so it reads from above. My drawer was a junk drawer before this, so the clear-out was its own small project. If yours is deep and messy, my deep kitchen drawers post has the steps.
Spice organization ideas for small kitchens
When we lived in a one-bedroom apartment, there was no spare drawer and the cabinets were full of plates. What worked there:
- A narrow rack screwed inside a cabinet door (renter-safe with command strips if the jars are light)
- A slim rolling cart, about 5 inches wide, that slid between the fridge and the wall
- A shallow basket on a pantry shelf for the less-used spices, so they could be pulled out in one go
I’d skip the magnetic tins on the fridge side if your fridge is next to the stove. Ours was, and it got warm. More ideas for tight kitchens are in how to organize a small kitchen.
Alphabetical, by cuisine, or by how often you use it?
I tried alphabetical first because it looked neat. It lasted about three weeks. When you’re cooking, you don’t think “C for cumin,” you think “taco night.”
Now I sort by how often I reach for it, and within that, loosely by meal. The weekly nine sit together in front. Then a baking group (cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, cloves, allspice, vanilla). Then a small “once in a while” group. My husband can find things without asking me, which is my real test of any system.
Refills come from the pantry, where I keep backup bags in one airtight bin. I walk through which containers I trust in airtight containers for the pantry.
Three spice organization mistakes I made
- Buying matching jars for everything. I spent an afternoon decanting into 24 identical jars, then couldn’t tell chili powder from paprika without the labels. Now I only decant spices that come in bags.
- Buying the big jar to save money. A huge jar of oregano lasted two years and tasted like nothing by the end. Small jars of the things I use less cost more per ounce and less in the trash.
- Keeping spices above the stove. It’s the most convenient spot and the worst one. Steam from the pot goes right up into that cabinet.
What didn’t work for me
A countertop spinning rack that came pre-filled with 20 spices. It looked lovely in the store. At home, half the jars were things I never cook with, they sat in the light next to the window, and the rack took up the one clear corner of counter I had. I donated it, jars and all, within a few months.
I also tried labeling the front of the shelf instead of the jars, like a store. The idea was that each spice always goes back to its spot. In real life, nobody in my house reads a shelf label. Labels on the lid are the only ones that get used.
Grab the free printable: my Spice Inventory Sheet, a one-page list to check off what you have, the date you opened it, and what to restock before holiday baking. Get the free sheet →
FAQ
What is the best way to organize spices?
Pull every jar out, toss the ones that have lost their smell, and combine duplicates. Then store them away from the stove, in a drawer insert or on a tiered riser, with the spices you use every week in the front. Sorting by how often you use them tends to last longer than alphabetical.
Where should spices not be stored?
Avoid the cabinet right above the stove, the spot next to the dishwasher, and a sunny windowsill. Heat, steam and light all weaken flavor. A cool cabinet or drawer a step or two away from the stove is better.
How do I organize spices in a small kitchen?
Use vertical spots that are usually empty: the inside of a cabinet door, a slim rolling cart beside the fridge, or one shallow basket on a pantry shelf. Keep only the spices you cook with regularly in the kitchen and refill them from a backup bin.
This week, pull out every jar and count them. Smell each one. I’d bet at least five of yours won’t make it back into the cabinet, and the ones that do will finally be easy to find, ginger included.
Get my free Home Reset Planner
The calm, room-by-room planner I use to reset my whole home without the overwhelm. Join the newsletter and I’ll send it straight to your inbox.
No spam, ever. Unsubscribe anytime. — Lena
Keep reading — more on Kitchen & Pantry

Pantry Cabinet Organization for Deep Shelves and No Walk-In

Chest Freezer Organization: How I Stopped Losing Food at the Bottom

Airtight Containers for Pantry: What’s Worth Decanting
